Scallops—a treasure trove from the sea, enigmatic in their simplicity, yet they dance on the palate with a complexity that can only be described as celestial.

They are a fanfare of flavor, waiting to be unlocked by the home chef. It’s not just about how to cook Costco scallops; it’s about transforming a humble bivalve into a feast for the senses.

Imagine: tender, buttery morsels that hint at the ocean’s depth, seared to golden perfection. The key is in the caress of heat, the aromatics that whisper secrets to the flesh, and the right kiss of seasoning.

In the journey you’re about to embark on, we’ll sail through the mist-shrouded realms of pan-frying and the art of thawing these frozen gems.

By the final punctuation mark, you’ll grasp the finesse of mastering Costco scallops, from garlic butter caresses to cooking times that ensure perfection.

The alchemy of transforming Costco’s wild scallops into a dinner-worthy of indulgence awaits. Prepare to unfurl the sails, as we chart a course to scallop excellence.

How To Cook Costco Scallops: The Quick Version

To cook Costco scallops, follow these steps:

  1. Thaw the scallops in a zip lock bag or overnight in the refrigerator.
  2. Remove the scallops from the bag and pat them dry with a paper towel. Reserve the scallop juices.
  3. Season the scallops with sea salt.
  4. Heat a stainless steel pan to medium-high heat. Add olive oil to coat the bottom of the pan.
  5. Reduce heat to medium, add a tablespoon of butter, and let it melt.
  6. Increase heat to high, place the scallops in the pan, and press them into the pan.
  7. Cook for two minutes, then turn the scallops over and press them into the pan again.
  8. Cook for two more minutes or until the scallops release easily from the pan.
  9. Plate the scallops and let them stand.
  10. Add the reserved scallop juices to the pan, whisk, and reduce the liquid.
  11. Pour the sauce over the scallops and serve them with your favorite vegetable or risotto.

This method ensures that the scallops are well-seared and flavorful, with a buttery sauce that enhances their taste. The scallops can be served with a variety of side dishes, such as risotto, pasta, or roasted vegetables, to create a satisfying and delicious meal.

Preparing Scallops for Cooking

YouTube player

Scallops are a gem from the ocean, a testament to the beauty and simplicity of seafood.

And Costco, that giant depot of nearly everything, provides these little morsels in generous quantities. But before we expose them to the heat, they need a bit of TLC.

Thawing frozen scallops

Begin here, because patience is not just a virtue; it’s crucial for the perfect texture of your scallops.

Take them out from the freezer and let them rest in the fridge. It’s a slow overnight process, or if short on time, a cold water bath can speed things up—keep them in their packaging or a leak-proof bag, and submerge.

Cleaning and preparation

Once thawed, each scallop might have a little tag-along—a side muscle that’s tougher than the rest. Peel it off.

You want uniformity, not a surprise chewy bit. A gentle rinse and a pat down with a paper towel will set them up for the next stage—seasoning.

Seasoning strategies

They say simplicity is the keynote of all true elegance. Salt and pepper could very well be enough, but if looking to cast a wider net with flavor, think garlic butter for richness or a citrusy marinade for some zest.

But take care; marinades can alter the tender texture of how to cook Costco scallops if left too long.

Cooking Methods

Here’s where the magic happens, the transformation from raw to bewitching bites.

Pan-Searing Scallops

Choosing the right pan and oil

High heat is your friend, and a non-stick or cast-iron pan will be your trusty ally. As for oil, something with a high smoke point—think avocado or grapeseed—is key.

Achieving a golden crust: temperature and timing

Heat the pan, then the oil, until it’s shimmering but not smoking. You’ll lay the scallops down and resist the urge to move them—patience once again is your shepherd to perfection.

Flavor enhancement tips: Butter basting and aromatics

In the final moments, a dollop of butter can create a baste that’s nectar for the scallops, and aromatics like garlic or thyme infuse them with whispers of flavor.

Baking Scallops

Preparing scallops for the oven

Be sure to preheat your oven and prepare a dish that is oven-appropriate. Space out your scallops, dress them up if you like, with a crumb topping or simple seasonings.

Temperature and time for perfect tenderness

A medium-high temperature, about 350-450°F, depending on the recipe’s direction, will suit them well. Keep a watchful eye; they’ll cook quickly, needing just minutes on each side.

Creative toppings and crusts

You can give Costco scallops a festive crust of panko bread crumbs, maybe mixed with a bit of parmesan or fine herbs. It gives texture and variety to the bite.

Grilling Scallops

Skewering for easy flipping

Now, if you’re venturing to the grill, skewering is a brilliant move. It keeps them from spinning when flipped and gives a handle for the turn.

Grill temperature and smoke points

A medium-hot grill is the sweet spot, allowing for a char without the burn, reconciling heat with the succulence of the scallop.

Marinades and glazes for grilling

Marinades and glazes not only amplify flavor but can also protect against the fierce heat, adding a caramelized layer that is quite the crown.

Broiling Scallops

Positioning scallops under the broiler

Getting them close to the broiler, around 4-6 inches, should do it. You want them teased by the fire, not engulfed.

Broiling time for a caramelized finish

Here, times can be even shorter than baking. Keep a vigilant stance, turning your gaze from them, and they might just overstep into rubberdom.

Using compound butters and broiling

A compound butter, herbed, or infused with garlic can usher scallops into brilliance under the high heat from above.

Advanced Techniques and Tips

With the basics comfortably nestled in your culinary repertoire, let’s elevate your plate.

Achieving restaurant-quality sear

The importance of dry scallops

Moisture is the nemesis of browning, so those scallops need to be bone dry before they kiss the pan.

High-heat cooking oils and techniques

Using the right oil and making sure your pan is rocket-hot will give you that sought-after restaurant-style sear.

Incorporating scallops into various cuisines

Asian-inspired recipes

Imagine your Costco scallops taking a dip in a soy-ginger glaze—yes, they’re cosmopolitan, sliding into varied cuisines with ease.

Mediterranean and Italian influences

Or how they might bathe in a tomato-based sauce with olives and capers—how to cook Costco scallops can be a tour through the Mediterranean in a single bite.

Pairing with sides and wines

Selecting complementary sides

Risotto might say “Italy,” while a mango salsa screams “tropical affair.”

Wine pairing basics: What works best with scallops

A crisp white wine, perhaps a Sauvignon Blanc, usually finds harmony with the delicate nature of scallops.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Remember, the path to perfect Costco scallops can be littered with pitfalls for the unwary.

Overcooking and undercooking

Identifying doneness: Visual cues and timing

They will go from translucent to opaque, signaling it’s time to step away from the stove.

Adjusting cooking times based on size and thickness

Larger or thicker Costco scallops may require a tad more time, but as standard, brief encounters with heat work best.

Incorrect pan and oil temperatures

Signs of the oil being too hot or not hot enough

Smoke is a no-go, shimmer is a green light, maintain that balance and the scallops will thank you.

How to adjust heat during cooking

If things start too aggressive, remove the pan for a spell, let the fury subside, then return to the flame.

Overcrowding the pan

The importance of cooking in batches

Each scallop deserves its space, their sear uninterrupted by the touch of a neighbor.

How overcrowding affects sear and texture

When the scallops are in each other’s pockets, they steam rather than singe, and that’s a tune we don’t want to hear.

Serving and Presentation

After the sounds of sizzling have subsided, the stage is set for the spectacle of plating.

Plating techniques for visual appeal

Color contrast and garnishing tips

Garnishes like a pinch of parsley or a twist of lemon can add visual zests, creating a feast for the eyes.

Using sauces and drizzles effectively

A drizzle of sauce can be a dove soaring across the meal’s landscape, bringing pieces together.

Creating a balanced meal

Pairing with vegetables and grains

Veggies and grains offer the perfect backup dancers for your Costco scallops—ensuring your plate is a symphony of tastes.

Considering dietary restrictions and preferences

Be thoughtful of your diners, scallops are versatile and can play well with gluten-free and low-carb companions alike.

Safety and Storage

Let’s not forget that scallops are still a catch from the wild blue, and as such, respect for their handling keeps us safe.

Proper storage of fresh and cooked scallops

Refrigerator storage guidelines

Keep fresh ones cold, cooked ones chill, and all within a seal that tells of an embrace from a refrigerator’s cool, safe arms.

Freezing and thawing practices

Freeze if you must, but remember, a thaw must come gently, not forced by heat but coaxed through cold patience.

Food safety considerations

Cross-contamination risks

Clean and separate; raw is raw, cooked is not, and never shall the twain meet on unwashed surfaces.

Cooking to safe temperatures

It’s a quick trip to doneness, but ensure you take it. No one wants their experience with scallops to turn sour.

FAQ On How To Cook Costco Scallops

Do Costco scallops need to be thawed before cooking?

Absolutely. For that ideal tenderness, thaw your scallops. Gently place them in the fridge overnight or for a quicker option, submerge them in a bowl of cold water. Avoid heat, as it can make the scallops tough.

What’s the best way to sear scallops from Costco?

Heat a pan with a touch of olive oil until it’s sizzling. Pat the scallops dry, season with salt, and lay them in the pan. Sear without moving them for a couple of minutes, then flip for that golden crust. Simplicity is often the pathway to deliciousness.

How long should I cook scallops for?

Cook scallops for about one to two minutes on each side. They should have a golden exterior and an opaque center. Overcooking is the nemesis of tender scallops, so watch them like a hawk and trust your intuition.

Can you cook Costco scallops from frozen?

You could, in theory, but for the best flavor and texture, thaw them first. Quick-cooking times mean any internal ice will prevent even cooking, and we want each bite to sing, not squeak.

What seasonings go well with scallops?

A classic duo is garlic butter and lemon – bright and rich. Feel free to explore – herb seasonings or a dusting of paprika can bring out the scallops’ sweet notes. They’re like an oceanic canvas, waiting for your brush.

Is it safe to eat Costco scallops raw?

Raw scallops are a delicacy if they’re sashimi-grade and handled properly. Costco’s might not fit that bill, so I recommend giving them a quick sear. Better safe than sorry, and just as tasty.

What’s the best pan for cooking scallops?

Non-stick pans are fantastic for ensuring your scallops don’t end up stuck and tough. A well-heated cast-iron skillet also gives a beautifully even sear, if you’re feeling a little rustic.

How do I know when scallops are cooked perfectly?

Perfectly cooked scallops will feel firm to the touch, look white and opaque, and should have a slight springiness. A translucent center means they need more time; if they’re rubbery, they’ve overstepped their welcome on the heat.

What are some good side dishes for scallops?

Scallops love company. Think a simple salad, buttery pasta, or some sautéed greens. A starchy contrast like risotto or roasted potatoes can also elevate your scallop game to the next level, turning a dish into a meal.

How to store leftovers of cooked Costco scallops?

Tuck any leftover scallops into an airtight container and refrigerate. Enjoy them within two days to savor their sea-kissed glory. Reheat gently, just until warm; treat them kindly, and they’ll return the favor.


And there it has it, the grand finale of our culinary concerto, how to cook Costco scallops to sheer perfection. We’ve danced through thawing without haste, embraced the golden sear, and harmonized with seasonings that sing of the sea and shore alike.

Dishes have been dazzled with these succulent morsels, and we’ve navigated the nuances of culinary arts that turn a simple seafood staple into an experience. Remember:

  • Gently thaw for that sublime texture.
  • Sear hot and fast for the perfect crust.
  • Embrace the garlicky embrace or citrus zing.
  • Pair with sides that let the scallops shine.

Cooking is a journey just as much as it’s a destination; each scallop is a chapter, each method a story. So here’s to the scallops that started in Costco’s aisles and finished in the heart of our homes—a standing ovation for the ocean’s gift, expertly prepared with a sprinkle of care and a dash of adventure.

If you liked this article about how to cook Costco scallops, you should check out this article about how to cook Costco pesto salmon.

There are also similar articles discussing how to cook Costco wingshow to cook Kirkland tortellinihow to cook Costco chicken alfredo, and how to cook Costco meatloaf.

And let’s not forget about articles on how to cook Costco frozen shrimphow to cook Costco porkhow to cook Crab legs from Costco, and how to cook Foster Farms mini corn dogs.

Categorized in: